Western Carolina University students within the School of Music department, specifically the Commercial Music and Audio Production concentration, are dealing with issues throughout the program that need to be addressed.
Katherine Boyd’s experience
Anyone who has met Katherine “Kat” Boyd knows she is meant to be behind a microphone.
When she isn’t bouncing between band practice or posting song covers from her room, she is finding ways to be on stage. Once her bedazzled pink microphone is in her hand, she guides listeners through handcrafted lyrics about relationships, grief and finding yourself.
“I went into the music program I guess because I really loved music. I mean, that’s kind of why everyone does it,” said Boyd. “I was telling my mom I was gonna go into communications because I felt it was more practical, and then I was getting crippling anxiety touring schools because I was like, I don’t want to do this. I want to do music, and it’s the only thing I want to do.”
She said that what led her to WCU was the unique Commercial Music and Audio Production concentration in the Music department.
She was looking for a program to hone her skills but found herself drowning in assignments with teachers who did not believe she had what it took. Formerly a voice and CMAP major, she recounts her experience.
“I started thinking that I was a bad musician, because of how critical everyone was,” said Boyd. “And I got to a point where I was like, I’m going to do what I want to do regardless. I know I want to be a musician, and I’ll be damned if I let a bunch of older white men tell me what I can and can’t do. So I left.”
She said that leaving her music major actually opened more music production opportunities.
“I actually have time, energy and excitement towards these projects rather than this nervousness that they won’t be liked or that they’re not good enough or tied up in this perfectionism that is encouraged in the music program,” said Boyd. “Like, after leaving, I have received so much support and so much self-confidence because I constantly don’t feel like there’s something to prove.”
WCU’s 2025 student body report showed that 756 students are enrolled in the College of Fine and Performing Arts, with 230 students enrolled for a music major. By fall of 2026, Western admitted a record breaking 2,386 freshman. WCU’s music program is ranked as one of the top music schools in North Carolina and with this wave of incoming freshmen, both present and former students think it’s time to reevaluate how the music program operates.
Music students from WCU reflect on their experiences at the School of Music, critiquing the lack of support from professors, overwhelming course load and restrictive environment.
Overwhelmed, overworked and underprepared
Students’ descriptions of the program often focus on one word: intense. Students are already operating on schedules that require a course overload, but it doesn’t end there.
“I’m in 19 credit hours right now… I will go into my trumpet ensemble that counts as like one or two credit hours, but I’m practicing for it for like three hours,” said DJ Dorky, a music education student preferring to go by his stage name. “I show up for it and we stay over all the time. So yes, technically I’m in 19 credit hours, which is already a course overload, but it translates to more work than it actually is on paper because of the amount of time that you spend doing things.”
Looking at the four year plans created by the school, the first semester for a music major sees students taking on nine classes. Of the six music classes in this proposed schedule, only one counts for three credits.
Demanding schedules make it near impossible for students of all walks to balance their social and academic lives.
“My work life balance has been pretty bad, and it’s taken me pretty much all four years to figure out how to make that balance. I also work two jobs and one of those jobs I’ve been with for two years,” said music tech senior Hannah Sagendorph. “So a lot of my life was just like, while I’m at school, I cram, and then six days a week I’m working in Waynesville, so I just kind of eat that time and move on.”
This work life balance is exacerbated by required concert attendance.
“You go to 10 events a semester, five of which are professional,” said DJ Dorky. “If a semester is X amount of days and you have to go to a concert 10 of those days, you might think it’s not that hard. But there are only concerts on maybe half of those days. And for professional concerts, there’s an even smaller number. For those of us who have to go and clock in at four and you don’t leave until, you know, 10:45, how am I supposed to find time at 7 to 11:30 to go see this concert? And if you don’t have it on a day when I’m off, I’m not gonna just take off work to go to this thing.”
On top of packed schedules the first two years of the music program are littered with classes with historically high failure rates meant to separate the students who “can” from the students that “can’t.”
“The fact that we had a professor with an insane grading rubric kept around, where over half of the class had withdrawn or failed, because of her teaching, and because of how stressed, unhappy, and unattainable her grading standards were, and they did nothing,” said Boyd. “They did nothing. There were students that changed their majors because of her, and they did nothing.”
The way teachers speak to students affects how students view their peers. This leaves students like DJ Dorky saying “there’s a very, very big divide” socially between students.
“I remember being in the trumpet studio and he was like, all right guys, call time’s at 7… and he was like, does anybody have a problem with that? I had to raise my hand in front of everybody and be like, I have a DJ gig starting at 9. And everybody snickered and laughed,” said DJ Dorky. “I’m not CMAP, but you can imagine what those kinds of people will think about people who are in CMAP and sing commercial music.”
The pitfalls of the CMAP program
Below you can listen to some of the main issues CMAP students have encountered within the program.
Johnathon Byers, a current piano major, talks about his previous attempt to bring major wide issues to light through a printed manifesto.
There is an informational error in this clip: Byers meant to say education department instead of english.
More than just a “pretty girl that sings”
CMAP students expressed that teachers’ dismissal of commercial music goes beyond classroom assignments and affects teachers’ perceptions of students’ capabilities.
Boyd recalls telling her advisor, Dr. Feken, about the issues she was encountering with other professors not seeing her a legitamte musician, but instead as a “dumb girl that sings.”
“He told me, ‘Well, you are a pretty girl. And if 49 out of 50 students present one way and you happen to be the exception, it’s easier to lump you in with the rest until you prove that you are different,’” said Boyd. “And I remember the second after that meeting, I wrote that down in my notes, so I could remember it forever because it struck me so hard that that was exactly how they saw me. As someone that had to prove, to beat this perception of myself, rather than someone who had already gotten in on her own merit.”
Boyd isn’t the only female CMAP student to feel that her abilities were overlooked and underestimated by a teacher.
“I don’t think there’s a conscious awareness of the gender dynamic. Like, there are five women in this class, you know?” said Sagendorph. “Let’s think about how our class talks about women in this field.”
The music industry is a historically male dominated field. In 2025 women held only 36.1% of spots on the most popular Billboard charts.
Students that observe or experience situations like this often are often unaware of how to approach it.
“There are so many women in that school that constantly feel lesser than to their male partners because of the way that teachers treat and view them. It is a problem,” said Boyd. “I know a girl that was in class and she got called a dumb broad by another student and the professor laughed. He did not say anything.”
It’s not that students don’t see it happening, it’s that students don’t feel like things can change.
“It’s like, sometimes I don’t feel like I have, like, full right to fully chat about it, ’cause I don’t know what it’s like. I’ve seen it,” said Byers. “And it’s like, especially with classical music, it’s almost normalized for some reason. I’m not sure why. I’m really not sure why. That’s something I want to see change too, but that’s like deeply rooted.”
Student proposed changes
Students want to see the program change. Dissatisfaction with the current execution of commercial music is at the top of the list.
“I think there needs to be commercial music specific professors for each concentration. I think that the fact that you have a bunch of classical professors attempting to teach commercial music, and therefore, their biases and lack of knowledge are slipping through, and putting that onto the students as their fault, because they are not well versed or comfortable in commercial music is ridiculous.” said Boyd.
Another proposed change aims to adjust the demanding concert attendance policy to make the program more accessible to working students.
“What I propose is a class from like 1:25 to 2:15,” said DJ Dorky. “Grab every single music major, put them into the auditorium, and have 10 different people perform in that time slot, every Wednesday, and all you have to do is show up and swipe your card to show that you were there for your attendance, and you can only miss X amount of days, otherwise you fail the course. So it fits within a work schedule, everybody’s gonna be there, and simultaneously, every performer will also have an audience… It’s disrespectful when someone’s performing an entire recital and no, not even like half of the audience is filled.”
Alternatively, one student suggests lengthening the program to lessen the workload shock on incoming students.
“It’s better to let people know what’s going to take time and spread it out without cramming information on people,” said Aliyah Jackson, current music industry senior.
No matter how the program goes forward, students agree that something has to change within the music program.
Staff response
Music program staff were contacted for comments but did not reply in a timely manner.



